CarePlus LogoHumana LogoCarePlus LogoHumana LogoCarePlus LogoHumana LogoCarePlus LogoHumana Logo
blankblankblankblankblankblankblankblankcarblankblankblankblankblankblankblankblankcar

Trusted guidance.

Real protection.

A local team that cares.

Whether you’re protecting your family, your business, or your future, we make insurance simple to understand—and even easier to trust.


Led by Sarah Ferguson, our agency is built on decades of local knowledge, personal service, and practical solutions for families and businesses in Reynoldsburg, Pickerington, Pataskala, Westerville, and Columbus.

Sarah Ferguson

Owner & Advisor

A white background with a few lines on it

Home Insurance

Peace of mind starts at home. We help you protect your biggest investment with clear coverage, no jargon, and guidance every step of the way.

Our Services

Expert Service, Every Step of the Way.

Insurance isn’t one-size-fits-all, and neither is our approach. We offer customized policies for homeowners, drivers, businesses, and more—partnering with top-rated carriers to provide the best coverage at the best value. Our team is here to help you find the right plan for your needs.

A white background with a few lines on it

Auto Insurance

From your daily commute to weekend drives, we’ll help you find affordable, reliable coverage that travels with you.

A white background with a few lines on it

Business Insurance

From your daily commute to weekend drives, we’ll help you find affordable, reliable coverage that travels with you.

A row of green stars on a white background.

Amanda

Sarah is amazing!! Super knowledgeable and friendly. Just all around awesome!

Mark Bingaman

Hey Sarah: Thanks so much for all your help a few weeks ago. You really were a lifesaver while I was on the auto accident scene and helped me handle the situation so well, I really appreciate it. Your immediate assistance and advice on the phone while I dealt with police and others was, and is, so appreciated. You and First Choice Insurance Solutions are awesome!

Robyn Burris

Sarah is very professional, knowledgeable, and answered my questions and concerns in a timely manner. I highly recommend!

Matthew Casto

Friendly, fast and explained my insurane policy so I could understand. Very pleased.

Whitney Briggs

Sarah is amazing!

Janelle Bailey

Sarah is very professional, personable, knowledgeable! I loved that she considered my personal situation and meet all of my needs!

Erika Warner

Sarah is an awesome agent. Available and flexible.

Elizabeth B

Sarah is great to work with! We won't go anywhere else for insurance!

Angela Love

I am so impressed with the level of service that I have received from Ferguson Insurance. Sarah helped me find the life insurance and disability insurance that were perfect for my life and budget. She is someone who really cares and goes the extra mile. My family is much better protected in case of a tragedy. Thank you Ferguson Insurance!

Marcus Martin

Sarah has been phenomenal. She's quick, responsive and has gone the extra mile multiple times to make sure not only did I have the right coverage but she also made sure my insurance was on file in the right places.

Lori M

Ferguson Insurance Advisors has been wonderful to work with. Sara is on top of things and she now has the business of my whole family. She makes herself available and works hard to get the best rates possible. Thanks for great customer service!!

seth kohler

Sarah helped walk me through the pros and conns of the different options and helped me find the best solution for my unique circumstances! Would recommend

Tracy Brown

Very Professional, Detailed in giving information, and meeting your needs. Process time was fast , I Highly recommend, looking forward to our future endeavors. TTP TRAINED TO PROTECT Tracy Brown

Abd Tarazi

Sarah was Great, quick accurate an responsive

Revonne Hammond

Sarah was very professional, courteous and so helpful in finding the right insurance for me at just the right time. When a problem occurred, not long after the policy began, she was there to help me with all the right answers. I felt I had an advocate with me. Thank you.

Bill Briggs

Quick, easy, and affordable, thanks Shara.

M Firelight

Sarah has expertise in many aspects of insurance. She was able to get me a better quote than 5 other agents. Her thorough knowledge of my industry and real estate helped make sure I had great coverage. In the end she helped file the paperwork to get me my refund from my old policy. Sarah really goes above and beyond.

Google User

I am so glad I switched to Ferguson Insurance advisors. Sarah Ferguson is so personable and helpful. She is patient, kind, and eagerly addresses any concerns I have. I wish I had switched to her sooner!

Boris Gadassik

Friendly, easy to reach, prompt communication, competitive and flexible rates. Recommended.

  • What types of insurance do you offer?

    We provide a wide range of personal and commercial insurance solutions, including homeowners, auto, life, and business insurance. Whether you're protecting your home, vehicle, or livelihood, we’ll help you find the right coverage to fit your unique needs.

  • How do I get a quote?

    Getting a quote is easy! You can request one online, call us directly, or stop by our office. We’ll take the time to understand your needs and walk you through your options, ensuring you get the right coverage at the right price.

  • Why should I choose a local insurance agency?

    Unlike big, impersonal companies, we provide hands-on service, personalized advice, and a deep understanding of our community’s needs. We’re committed to building long-term relationships and helping our clients make informed insurance decisions.

  • Can I bundle my home and auto insurance?

    Yes! Bundling your home and auto insurance can save you money and simplify your policies. We work with top-rated insurance carriers to find you the best possible rates and discounts when combining multiple policies.

  • What should I do if I need to file a claim?

    If you need to file a claim, we’re here to help. Contact our office right away, and we’ll guide you through the process. We’ll work with your insurance carrier to ensure your claim is handled quickly and fairly, so you can get back to what matters most.